TY - JOUR
T1 - Perceived Support Is Not Psychological Change
T2 - Reframing AI Chatbots in Mental Health Care
AU - Mahat-Shamir, Michal
AU - Payes, Maya
AU - Kagan, Maya
N1 - Publisher Copyright:
© Michal Mahat-Shamir, Maya Payes, Maya Kagan. Originally published in JMIR AI.
PY - 2026
Y1 - 2026
N2 - AI chatbots are increasingly used for emotional support, often outside formal care. Emerging evidence suggests that generative systems may produce modest reductions in symptoms of depression and anxiety. Yet a change in symptoms alone does not clarify the nature of the process involved. This viewpoint argues that chatbot interactions may primarily operate through structured mirroring and self-reflection rather than through the intersubjective engagement that underpins therapeutic transformation. We propose an implementation-focused distinction between tools that support symptom regulation and engagement and interventions that aim at enduring psychological change, emphasizing the need to specify mechanisms, relational conditions, and appropriate care pathways. Conflating perceived support with psychological change risks redefining therapeutic standards around technological affordance rather than relational encounters. As AI chatbots become embedded in mental health ecosystems, conceptual clarity and digital emotional literacy are essential to ensure that innovation strengthens rather than replaces the relational foundations of care.
AB - AI chatbots are increasingly used for emotional support, often outside formal care. Emerging evidence suggests that generative systems may produce modest reductions in symptoms of depression and anxiety. Yet a change in symptoms alone does not clarify the nature of the process involved. This viewpoint argues that chatbot interactions may primarily operate through structured mirroring and self-reflection rather than through the intersubjective engagement that underpins therapeutic transformation. We propose an implementation-focused distinction between tools that support symptom regulation and engagement and interventions that aim at enduring psychological change, emphasizing the need to specify mechanisms, relational conditions, and appropriate care pathways. Conflating perceived support with psychological change risks redefining therapeutic standards around technological affordance rather than relational encounters. As AI chatbots become embedded in mental health ecosystems, conceptual clarity and digital emotional literacy are essential to ensure that innovation strengthens rather than replaces the relational foundations of care.
KW - digital literacy
KW - digital mental health
KW - generative artificial intelligence
KW - psychological change
KW - therapeutic alliance
UR - https://www.scopus.com/pages/publications/105051869110
U2 - 10.2196/94503
DO - 10.2196/94503
M3 - ???researchoutput.researchoutputtypes.contributiontojournal.article???
AN - SCOPUS:105051869110
SN - 2817-1705
VL - 5
JO - JMIR AI
JF - JMIR AI
M1 - e94503
ER -